Buying vs. Renting in Arcadia, CA — Is It Worth Buying at $1,199,000?

With home prices in Arcadia continuing to rise and interest rates stabilizing around 6.25%, many residents are asking: “Is it better to buy or rent?” Let’s compare the numbers for a $1,199,000 home purchase using 95% conventional financing with forecasted appreciation of 5.54% per year over the next 9 years.


📊 Buying Scenario

  • Home Price: $1,199,000
  • Down Payment (5%): $59,950
  • Loan Amount: $1,139,050
  • Interest Rate: 6.25%
  • APR: 6.397%
  • Monthly Mortgage (P&I): ~$7,006
  • Property Taxes (1.25%): ~$1,249/month
  • Home Insurance + PMI + Maintenance: ~$900/month
  • Total Monthly Payment~$9,155/month

📈 Appreciation & Equity

  • Annual Appreciation: 5.54%
  • Estimated Home Value in 9 Years: ~$2,010,000
  • Estimated Loan Balance in 9 Years: ~$1,021,000
  • Estimated Equity in 9 Years~$989,000

🏠 Renting Scenario

  • Current Rent Estimate for Comparable Home in Arcadia: ~$5,500/month
  • Annual Rent Increase Estimate: 4%
  • Total Rent Paid Over 9 Years~$664,000
  • Equity Gained: $0

💡 Summary

MetricBuyingRenting
Total Cost Over 9 Years~$987,000 (net of equity)~$664,000
Estimated Equity Gained~$989,000$0
Net Gain/Loss+$2,000+ in equity vs cost-$664,000 (no equity)

🧠 Bottom Line: Even though buying has higher upfront and monthly costs, the long-term appreciation in Arcadia builds substantial wealth. After 9 years, you could walk away with nearly $1 million in equity, far outpacing the cost of renting.