Buying vs. Renting in Agoura Hills, CA (2025)


As a mortgage professional, I understand the importance of making informed decisions when it comes to housing. Let’s delve into a comprehensive comparison between buying and renting in Agoura Hills, CA, considering current market data and forecasts.

📊 Current Market Snapshot

  • Median Home Price: Approximately $1.57 million as of February 2025, reflecting a significant year-over-year increase of 147.2%.
  • Average Rent: Around $3,675 per month for all property types.
  • Estimated Mortgage Rate: 6.25% for a 30-year fixed loan.

💸 Monthly Cost Comparison

ScenarioMonthly CostNotes
Buying$9,700Includes mortgage, taxes, insurance, and maintenance.
Renting$3,675Based on average rent for all property types.

*Note: The buying scenario assumes a 20% down payment and includes estimated property taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs.


📈 Forecasted Home Appreciation in Agoura Hills

Historical data indicates that Agoura Hills has experienced substantial home value appreciation. While specific future projections are not available, past trends suggest a strong growth trajectory.


📉 Rent vs. Buy: 9-Year Financial Outlook

Over a 9-year period, the financial implications of buying versus renting can be significant. While renting may offer lower monthly costs initially, buying can lead to substantial equity gains over time.

Here’s a detailed cost comparison between renting and buying a home in Agoura Hills, CA over 9 years, based on realistic assumptions:


🏡 Buying a Home in Agoura Hills

Assumptions:

  • Home Price: $1,570,000
  • Down Payment (20%): $314,000
  • Loan Amount: $1,256,000
  • Interest Rate: 6.25% (30-year fixed)
  • Monthly Mortgage Payment: ~$7,743
  • Property Taxes (1.25%): ~$19,625/year
  • Insurance: $2,000/year
  • Maintenance (1%): $15,700/year

📦 Estimated Total Cost of Buying Over 9 Years

YearCumulative MortgageTaxes, Insurance, MaintenanceTotal Cost
1$92,916$37,325$130,241
2$185,832$74,650$260,482
3$278,748$111,975$390,723
4$371,664$149,300$520,964
5$464,580$186,625$651,205
6$557,496$223,950$781,446
7$650,412$261,275$911,687
8$743,328$298,600$1,041,928
9$836,244$335,925$1,172,169

🏠 Renting in Agoura Hills

Assumptions:

  • Starting Rent: $3,675/month
  • Annual Rent Increase: 4%

📦 Estimated Total Rent Cost Over 9 Years

YearMonthly RentAnnual RentCumulative Cost
1$3,675$44,100$44,100
2$3,822$45,864$89,964
3$3,975$47,699$137,663
4$4,134$49,607$187,270
5$4,300$51,591$238,861
6$4,472$53,655$292,516
7$4,651$55,801$348,317
8$4,837$58,033$406,350
9$5,030$60,354$466,704

🔍 Summary: 9-Year Comparison

MetricRentingBuying
Total Cost$466,704$1,172,169
Equity Built$0$370,000+ (estimate)
Ownership❌ No ownership✅ Home equity growth
Flexibility✅ High❌ Lower
Stability❌ Rent increases✅ Fixed mortgage

🏁 Conclusion

While renting in Agoura Hills offers lower monthly expenses, buying a home can be a strategic long-term investment, especially considering the area’s historical appreciation rates. It’s essential to evaluate your financial situation, long-term goals, and market conditions before making a decision.

*Disclaimer: This analysis is based on available data as of May 2025 and is for informational purposes only. Actual costs and market conditions may vary.

David Delgado – NMLS #349079
President/CEO
Main Office (866) 587-6927
Freedom Choice Lending
NMLS #1998153

www.FreedomChoiceLending.com

P.S.  If you know any friends, family members, co-workers looking to buy, sell or refinance it would be an honor to help them as well.  When you come across anyone please give us a call at 866-587-6927 Thank you! David Delgado